External storage feels boring until you need it. Then it becomes the hero on your desk. I spent time with two four-bay Icy Box enclosures. The IB-3740-C31 and the IB-RD3640SU3 look similar at first glance. They target very different needs once you plug them in. This review covers design, setup, performance, and daily use. I also explain which model fits which type of user.
Icy Box send me these products in exchange for a review. This is my own opinion and Icy Box had no say in it (and still don’t). The review is about the two big boxes underneath. The other products get a review as well. Currently quite busy with them.

About Icy Box
Icy Box is part of RaidSonic Technology in Germany. The brand focuses on practical storage hardware for home and work. The range includes single drive cases, dual bay docks, and four bay towers. You will also find NVMe cases, USB hubs, chargers, and card readers. The goal is simple gear that lasts, with clear status lights and sturdy housings.
My past experience with Icy Box has been steady. Their cases use a lot of metal to help cooling. Trays are simple to handle. LEDs are clear. The manuals are not flashy but get the job done. When you move terabytes, you want that kind of attitude. No nonsense, just tools that work.

Why external storage helps PC and laptop users
Modern laptops often ship with small internal SSDs. Desktops fill up faster than you expect when you shoot 4K video or play large games. A four bay enclosure adds big capacity without opening your system. You keep the clean look of your laptop or small form factor desktop. You also get room to grow later.
Plug and play setup
Both units connect with a single cable to start. Your operating system sees each drive, or a RAID set, like any other disk. You can format, copy files, and set up backups right away. No drivers were needed in my tests on Windows and macOS. Linux support worked fine for JBOD and standard file systems.
Speed, safety, or both
Storage needs vary by person and project(s). Some users want raw speed for scratch files. Some users want safety for family photos or client work. The IB-3740-C31 leans toward simple speed and clean setup. The IB-RD3640SU3 brings RAID levels for extra protection or striping. Pick the model that matches the job you do most days.
My two cents: As a reviewer I get lot’s of questions from readers asking “Hi Dutchiee, just having a backup system (like a NAS or the 3740), would that just be enough to back-up everything to it?” – Unfortunately not. A system like this can also fail, especially if you use the JBOD version (will come back to that in a bit). A NAS can be stolen, a building can burn down (with your storage in it). Make always sure that you make an extra (even better offsite) backup of your important documents and whatever you like. In this case it’s often; Gone is gone…
Meet the two models
IB-3740-C31 in short
The IB-3740-C31 supports four 2.5 inch or 3.5 inch SATA drives. It connects over USB 3.1 Gen 2 Type C at up to 10 Gbit per second. It runs in single disk mode, often called JBOD. Each drive mounts on its own. There is no RAID feature in this model. The chassis uses aluminum with plastic panels. A front flap door keeps things tidy. Cooling uses an 80 mm fan with auto and manual speed modes. See the IB-3740-C31 specifications for a full list.

IB-RD3640SU3 in short
The IB-RD3640SU3 supports four 3.5 inch SATA drives. It offers RAID 0, 1, 3, 5, 10, and single disk modes. Host links include USB 3.0 at 5 Gbit per second and eSATA. Drive slots are trayless, which makes swaps quick. Cooling uses an 80 mm fan with thermal control. The manual covers RAID switches and indicators in detail. See the IB-RD3640SU3 manual and specs.
Funny enough the 3640 differs not that much with the 3740. The only thing is that it has more leds for the type of raid, fan, and drive status. Of course, it also has e-sata and USB 3.0, and those leds are also at the front.

Hardware tour and setup
Build and layout
Both cases feel sturdy on the desk. Panels fit well. Doors close with a clean click. Rubber feet keep each enclosure stable during heavy disk activity. The 3740 front flap makes the bays easy to reach. The 3640 trayless slots are even faster for swaps. LEDs show power, activity, and status per bay. The 3640 adds RAID status lights.
Cooling and noise
Each unit has one 80 mm fan at the rear. The 3740 fan offers auto and manual levels. That cut idle noise in my room. The 3640 fan ramps with drive temps. In a quiet office you will hear both units during heavy writes. During light use the 3740 sat at a lower pitch. That made it easier to ignore. However, if you put it next to you when you are trying to sleep, you might throw the thing out of your window. So yeah, it’s fine for daily use, but not great to sleep next to. But I ask you.. What NAS is… of this price …?

Power and sleep
Both units use external power bricks (which is connected on the side, which is new for me – never had this in my storage system reviews).
On the 3740, sleep and standby behavior worked as expected. When the host shut down, the unit went to sleep. The 3640 can also sleep, raid activity can wake or keep it up.
Specifications compared
| Feature | IB-3740-C31 | IB-RD3640SU3 |
|---|---|---|
| Drive bays | 4 × 2.5 or 3.5 inch SATA | 4 × 3.5 inch SATA |
| Host link | USB 3.1 Gen 2 Type C, 10 Gbit per second | USB 3.0, 5 Gbit per second, plus eSATA |
| Modes | Single disk per bay, JBOD | RAID 0, 1, 3, 5, 10, single |
| Cooling | Rear 80 mm fan, auto or manual | Rear 80 mm fan, thermal control |
| Indicators | LED per drive, system and fan status | LED per drive, RAID status lights |
| Tray system | Front flap door with caddies | Trayless slots for quick swaps |
| Target user | Laptop and desktop users who want simple speed | Users who want redundancy or striped arrays |
Test bench and method
I used four Toshiba 16 TB 7200 RPM SATA drives for baseline tests. I ran large copy jobs and common benchmarks. For the 3640 I tested RAID 5 and RAID 0. For the 3740 I tested single disk mode. I also tried two SATA SSDs to see how the 3740 scales with faster media. Ambient room temperature sat near 21 degrees Celsius.
Performance results
IB-3740-C31 speed
With four hard drives in single disk mode, the 3740 reached 275 MB per second reads. Writes landed near 240-250MB per second in long transfers. With two SATA SSDs installed, peak reads moved toward 600MB per second. The USB 3.1 Gen 2 link gives headroom for faster disks. Each drive mounts on its own, so you can copy between bays with ease.
IB-RD3640SU3 speed
With four hard drives in RAID 5, the 3640 reached 500-560 MB per second reads. Writes landed around 500MB per second in large copy jobs. RAID 0 raised reads to near 550per second. eSATA gave stable long runs in my copy tests.
Thermals in practice
Under sustained writes, hard drive temps sat between 42 and 48 degrees. The 3740 ran slightly cooler at similar loads. The 3640 fan ramped sooner during RAID rebuilds, which makes sense. Noise was present but never distracting next to a desktop tower. On a kitchen table, or when it’s standing next to your couch when you watch a movie on Plex, you would notice it more.
Daily use and workflow notes
For editors and creators
Video editors often face tight deadlines and large files. The 3740 makes a strong scratch drive station for proxies and assets. You get clean plug and play over USB C. If you need fault tolerance during a long project, the 3640 in RAID 5 feels safer. A drive can fail without losing the timeline. Rebuilds take time, so pick a quiet window for that job. And still, I cannot stress it enough – especially if your job hangs on it – make sure you make extra backups. So yes. Backup of a backup. Backupsception. But only to really really keep the most important things.
For photographers
Photo libraries grow fast with RAW files and stacks. The 3740 gives flexible bays for SSDs and HDDs. Put current work on SSDs for quick culling. Move older shoots to large HDDs. If you sleep better with parity, run the 3640 in RAID 5 and mirror to the cloud on a schedule. The extra step saves stress later.
For gamers
Game folders eat free space faster than almost any workload. I mean my Origin (EA Play) folder is 220GB with 4 games (it’s even bigger on a different drive). In a few weeks Battlefield 6 will come out and will be around 60GB as well. At some point the storage stops. The awesome thing is that a device like the 3740 can just copy (and store locally) your less played games or different documents or other files. Keep fast loading titles on an SSD bay. Your laptop stays lean, yet your library stays one click away.

For families and students
Shared devices can use one of these enclosures as a central vault. The 3640 with RAID 1 or RAID 5 keeps family photos safe from a single drive failure. The 3740 keeps setup simple for mixed laptops in a home. A single USB C cable beats cracking open a PC for a spare bay.
Key differences that affect your choice
- RAID support matters for safety. The 3640 offers parity or mirroring. The 3740 does not.
- Drive mix flexibility favors the 3740. It fits both 2.5 inch and 3.5 inch drives.
- Quick swaps favor the 3640. Trayless bays are fast during rebuilds or tests.
- Noise at idle favors the 3740. Its fan logic stayed calmer in my room. But still noticeable.
- Legacy links favor the 3640. eSATA support fits some older workstations. The tech market is moving in a different direction, so make sure you make a good choice – also for your future products which have or lack certain connections.
Feature breakdown
Connectivity and cables
The 3740 ships with a USB C cable in most retail boxes. Always use a good cable for 10 Gbit per second links. See USB C cable speeds explained. The 3640 includes a USB A cable and supports eSATA for older systems.
Backups and the 3-2-1 rule
Hardware can fail. People can make mistakes. A simple plan saves the day. Keep three copies of your data on two types of media, with one copy off site. Wired explains that method well for home users. See how to back up your computer to any cloud service.
When to pick RAID
RAID helps uptime more than it helps backups. RAID 1 mirrors data on two drives. RAID 5 adds parity across the set. A single drive can fail without losing the volume. That buys time to replace the bad unit. RAID does not replace a separate backup. PCMag offers a clear primer. See what is RAID.
Drive health and failure stats
Hard drives fail over time. Backblaze shares drive failure data from large pools. The reports give a sense of patterns by age and model. See hard drive stats. Your small set will vary, yet the habit of regular checks helps. Replace noisy or slow drives before they cause drama.
Commentary from daily use
Both enclosures stayed stable during long copy jobs. The 3740 felt like a friendly tool for most laptop users. The single cable setup and simple bay logic encouraged clean habits. The 3640 felt like a guardian for large work folders. I slept better with a RAID 5 set holding client projects. I still ran a cloud backup, since accidents can happen.
I liked the 3640 trayless slots during testing. I moved drives in and out without fumbling with screws. The 3740 door kept dust out and looked neat on a shelf. Small things matter when you stare at a box all week. It’s just clean, both of them.
Downsides to note
- The 3740 lacks RAID. If a drive fails, that bay’s data is gone.
- The 3640 uses USB 3.0. Link speed caps performance with fast SSDs.
- Both units make fan noise under heavy writes. Place them a bit away.
- Rebuilds on the 3640 take time. Plan a window to replace a drive.
Which one should you buy
Pick the IB-3740-C31 if you want easy setup and higher link speed. It suits users who mix SSDs and HDDs and keep backups elsewhere. It also suits editors who want a fast scratch pool with simple cable life.
Pick the IB-RD3640SU3 if you value parity or mirroring. It suits users who hold client data or family archives and want safety from a single drive fault. The interface is slower, yet the peace of mind is real.
And yes, remember to make back-ups of important things. So backup of a backup.
Verdict
Both units serve clear roles. The IB-3740-C31 offers speed and simple setup for most users. It pairs well with modern laptops and mixed media. The IB-RD3640SU3 offers parity and peace of mind for larger archives. It pairs well with desktops that host many long term files. If you edit daily on a laptop, start with the 3740 and a cloud backup. If you guard client data on a desktop, pick the 3640 and run RAID 5 with regular off site copies (yes I know I said it several times – but it’s for your safety).
For me, the real winner was the IB-RD3640SU3 with all it’s features. But, like stated; they both serve clear but different roles.
In my opinion both of them deserve 5 out of 5 stars. Absolutely worth it!
Frequently asked questions
1. Can I mix drive sizes in one unit
Yes. The system will not force matching sizes in JBOD. For RAID on the 3640, the array uses the smallest size across drives. Matching sizes keeps the math simple.
2.Do these work with Macs and PCs
Yes. Both worked on my Windows and macOS systems without drivers. Format the volume to a file system that fits your mix of devices.
3.Can I hot swap drives
Yes. The 3640 trayless slots help with quick swaps. Avoid pulling a drive during a rebuild. The 3740 trays are easy to handle for swaps in single disk mode.
4.How loud are they
Under light use, both stay modest. Under heavy writes, you will hear the fans. The 3740 sat at a lower pitch in my room.
5.How long do RAID 5 rebuilds take
Times vary by drive size and workload. If you use 16TB drives, it will take a few days.
6.Do I need special cables for 10 Gbit per second
Use a quality USB C cable from Icy Box rated for 10 Gbit per second. Shorter cables help stability.
7.Can I start with two drives and add more later
Yes. On the 3740, each bay mounts as a single disk. On the 3640, you can expand by building a new array or using single mode. Backup first, then grow with care.
8.Does the 3640 support eSATA on current laptops
Most modern laptops lack eSATA ports. Use the USB 3.0 link instead. Older workstations may still benefit from eSATA.
9.Should I use SSDs or HDDs
SSDs win for speed and low noise. HDDs win for cheap bulk storage. Many users run a mix in the 3740 for a balanced setup.
10.What about power loss during writes
Use a small UPS if you write to arrays often. A brief power drop can corrupt an active write. A UPS keeps the box alive long enough to finish.
Sources
- Icy Box IB-3740-C31 specifications
- Icy Box IB-RD3640SU3 manual and specs
- Icy Box IB-3740-C31 product page
- Icy Box IB-RD3640SU3 product page



